SPOILER ALERT!!! I’ll be ranting about this book… if you haven’t read it and don’t want to hear about it, don’t read this. Otherwise, continue at your own risk. And I think this may be a long rant…
So, let me start out by saying… I liked it, it wasn’t bad. It wasn’t my favorite though. I was kind of weirded out in the middle, and I wasn’t really sure why, but it seemed like our beloved Steph was influenced slightly by the casting of the movie. maybe I’m being too picky, but since when does Edward “chuckle and run his free hand through his tousled bronze hair”? pg 13 if you care… Rob Pattinson does that. not Edward. I also felt like Bella changed a lot through the book, at least in her personality. while I like that she’s not as wishy-washy as she was in the previous books, it just wasn’t the Bella I was used to having narrate the stories.
I was especially weirded out by the whole “Bella having Edward’s half-vampire-half-human baby”. and everything that went along with that. while she sounds cute as a button, it was just odd for me. I definitely didn’t expect that… partly because I didn’t think Edward would consent to a honeymoon night like that without backing out at the last minute, (for fear of hurting Bella, not anything else, although he did whine about that a bit) and partly because I didn’t think it was possible even if they did get it on after the wedding. and the fact that the pregnancy, and the Renesmee’s accelerated growth (not to mention the hybrid name to match the hybrid baby… I call her Ran) didn’t really help a whole lot. it was a bit whirlwind-ish, which I think is what Stephenie was going for, but I had trouble catching it all.
and of course Bella goes to rose for help about the baby. of course. use that to your advantage, Bells. good job. *scowls* Rosalie has grown on me, but I thought that was cheap. obviously Edward and Carlisle knew what was up, and they tried to get Bella to comply. but being stubborn Bella, she wouldn’t. and look! it nearly ended up killing you Bella. but Edward (finally) changed you, so I guess you got your wish. you just went about it in an odd way.
I wasn’t too sure how much I liked Jake having his random bit of storytelling in the middle. I understand why Steph wrote it that way, and I think it was a good idea, but being in Jake’s head isn’t where I want to be usually. if she was going to switch point of views, I would have rather it been from Edward’s POV. but then again, as much as I love the stupid shiny Volvo owner, and I think he is exponentially better for Bella than Jake, I think his self-torture and internal dialogue could get a bit redundant. and I was mad about his moping after the first real honeymoon night. obviously Bella was fine with it (till she saw the bruises at least…) so suck it up. she’s happy… you be happy too. you have her. that’s more than you were getting in new moon.
then there’s the whole imprinting thing. Jake. and Renesmee. TOTALLY didn’t see that one coming. like holy crap. I had to stop for a minute to comprehend that one. but then again, it does make perfect sense, and I’m glad Jake finally has someone other than Bella. even though I’m team vampire, Jacob deserves his happiness too. and obviously ren is that for him. (yeah the whole nessie nickname totally makes me think of the loch ness monster before Bella even mentioned it. lol
I like ren better. even though it’s not as cutsie)
especially after Bella was changed, I felt like her personality changed a lot too. I knew that she was going to be more confident and stuff, and I guess I didn’t really know how she was going to react to the whole vampire thing, but I didn’t expect this. she’s going off on her own to some other town, getting forged documents, being all business-lady-like. that doesn’t fit the Bella I’ve come to know in the first three books. she grows up a lot I think, but I guess she would have after having a vampire’s baby.
Edward (ah, my beloved Edward) also didn’t seem the same. he was stressing out more than he usually does during Bella’s pregnancy. which I guess I should have expected, but Jake’s description of him being “half crazed” just doesn’t fit the Edward I’ve come to know and love. was he like that in the ballet studio when Bella was staring death in the face? what about when they were in Italy with the Volturi? was he losing it then? if he was, Bella’s oblivious as a narrator. but I don’t know how reliable bells OR Jake are as narrators. they each see different things differently. but personally, I wasn’t quite sure that Edward should have been reacting so violently to Bella. maybe he started loving the unborn child also, and didn’t want to lose them both? I don’t know… but he’s certainly dealt with his fair share of dying-almost-dying, so why is reaction so different now? was it just the fact that they were finally married, and if she died giving birth he may not be able to change her? I don’t know… I have to remind myself also that during the first few chapters, (especially ch 5, isle Esme) the whole honeymoon thing is just as new to him as it is to Bella. So his nerves are explained.
the Volturi intervention near the end… whatever. I expected them to come and Caius to be all like ahhhh-you-all-die-now-because-i-have-this-insatiable-need-to-kill-or-get-revenge-on-everyone. Bella’s bubble thing was cool though… I didn’t know she could push it out like that. definitely helpful.
Alice leaving made me sad. even though I KNEW she would come back… it wouldn’t be Alice if she didn’t… it still made me sad. I knew why she did, and why she took jazz with her, but still. it sucked. I also didn’t see as much of the Cullens as I would have liked too… and a little too much of jake/seth/leah. yes, Carlisle was there. but not a lot. Esme… I always feel like she takes the back burner. I was looking forward to getting to know her a bit better. all in all, I was just looking forward to seeing a bit more Cullen family dynamics. family hunt or something. not that we didn’t really see the family working together at the end of eclipse, but still.
I feel bad leaving it on a sour note. solo… I thought that the second to last page… definitely my favorite. Just knowing that Edward finally gets to hear Bella’s mind, even if it’s not for that long, totally made me cry. I’m not even sure why. maybe it’s just because that’s the only thing he’s never truly been able to have, and I just love him too much to see him deprived
not my favorite, but I’d still recommend it. but the first book, twilight, will always be my favorite.
Alright… rant over.